π¦"So, are we doing your family or mine this year?"
Published 10 days agoΒ β’Β 2 min read
|
The Calendar Issue
It starts with a simple question about Thanksgiving. Twenty minutes later, you're somehow talking about whose mom is harder to say no to and why one of you always gives in.
|
|
Splitting the holidays looks like a scheduling problem.
Two families, a handful of dates, one calendar. Should be easy.
Except each family comes with its own idea of what the holidays are supposed to be. One side does a big gathering with thirty people and a gift for everyone. The other keeps it small and thinks spending a lot is a little much. Neither is wrong. They're just different, and the two of you are standing in the middle.
So the conversation about dates turns into something else. Whose traditions count more. Who gave in last year. Whether your partner gets why missing a year at home feels like such a big deal.
That's why this one tends to go better early. In mid-November there's still room to talk. The week before, it's mostly damage control.
|
|
|
Each family's version of the holidays has a price tag, and it's rarely the same one.
Flying to one side can mean a few hundred dollars per person once you add the ride to the airport and the bag fee. Driving to the other might be cheap in gas but mean a hotel, because there's no room at the house. Then there are gifts. If one family expects a present for every niece and nephew and the other does a $25 grab bag, your gift budget looks completely different depending on where you land.
Couples often argue about these costs one at a time, which is how a $60 gift card turns into a fight about respect. It usually helps to put both versions side by side: travel, gifts, food, and time off work. Seeing the full number for each makes it easier to talk about tradeoffs instead of loyalty.
Some couples alternate years. Some split the day. Some pick one big holiday each and keep the rest small. There's no right formula, just the one you can both afford and both live with.
|
|
|
Ask your partner one question tonight: "What's the one art of the holidays you'd really miss if we skipped it?"
Hear their answer before you share yours. Planning around the one thing each of you cares about most is way easier than trying to protect everything.
|
|
|
Eight Dates: Essential Conversations for a Lifetime of Love by John and Julie Gottman
This book walks couples through eight guided conversations, including one on money and one on family. It's built for talking, not lecturing, and works whether you've been together six months or twenty years. Worth checking your library for.
|
|
|
For couples still at the start of this, it can help to each jot down your ideal plan separately comparing, so neither of you is just reacting to the other.
Once you've decided, telling both families in the same week keeps anyone from hearing it secondhand and taking it personally.
If the same holiday argument shows up every single year, our couples therapy looks at money and relationship stress together, and we accept several insurance plans for it.
|
|
|
Which holiday tradition did you pick up from your family without ever deciding you actually liked it?
Forward this to your partner. It's easier than bringing it up cold.
|
|
|
|